Overloaded: Counterfeit & Substandard Goods Swamp Developing Economies

NO RATINGS
View comments: newest first | oldest first | threaded
TIOLUWA
User Rank
Blogger
Re: A Dynamic challenge
TIOLUWA   11/4/2010 9:04:57 AM
NO RATINGS

Hardcore,

interesting angle to the issue, you raised some issues that i didn't know about.

and yes, i totally agree with you, alot of house cleaning on the part of manufacturers will be needed to tackle the issues.

Hardcore
User Rank
Supply Network Guru
Re: A Dynamic challenge
Hardcore   11/3/2010 8:08:53 PM
NO RATINGS
1 saves

 

Hi,

There are some interesting points of view from various people,

but I think a valuable point has been missed.

One issue is that 'many' of the so called counterfeits are not actually 'fake', which may account for why some manufacturers are less talkative on the subject.

Certainly in China there are outright cases of fakes , consider the situation recently at "sparkfun"

http://www.sparkfun.com/commerce/news.php?id=364

Now the interesting pint here is the Xray pictures,  there has been a 'deliberate' attempt to make the part look like a genuine part, or it is another IC  functional part that has been re-branded.

Then we have issues related to outright fraud:

http://www.hkinventory.com/public/ReportedCompanyResult.asp

(Seriously I cannot believe people would actually send cash to people registered with gmail addresses)

The above cases are obviously outright fraud.

Then we can consider  the issue of 'dummy parts'  or pre-production parts, which some manufacturers provide to allow profiling of solder processes without the destruction of genuine parts (unfortunately many of these 'genuine dummy' parts look very realistic)

other situations are less clear and consist of  're-branding' of  genuinely manufacturers parts.

In some of these  manufacturers parts are covered by NDA and proprietary data sheets that outline the defects in the parts. (Nand-flash memory is one area where this is rampant)

A purchase of such material , followed by a 'laser etch' of the top surface of the package, then provides the opportunity to 'rebrand' with a laser.

The issue is not  that the goods are fake, but that they are 'genuine' defective parts supplied into the market by semi manufacturers attempting to maximize their bottom line, worse still these parts have passed completely through the correct distribution channels.

The only way to sort out such parts is to have  deep analysis performed by the actual manufacturer, since  the silicon belongs to them.

Then there is the 'filter down' system, very common in China.

A manufacturer buys parts from a supplier  but during their incoming IQC, defective parts are replaced  by the manufacturer at a given % without the need to return sub-spec parts.

These sub spec parts are then supplied into the market at a lower cost and re-enter the process, where they are screened by the next level down.

Defects are again returned to the market. and so… on , until the absolute dregs of functionality are left, at this stage the parts are bought by the 'Kg'

Even at this level there is still an outlet for these parts, many end up in substandard products proceed by small factories selling onto E-bay.

Again Nand-Flash memory is one such component.

Even more worrying is that in some cases the integral manufacturing ID, is non-functional, or the ID is that of a 'competitor' who has supplied a short fall of dies to be packaged up into another competitors package (all perfectly legitimately), but then when things go wrong with such parts, everyone involved denies responsibility.

Before the market can be cleaned up, the manufacturers first need to get their house in order.

 

 

TIOLUWA
User Rank
Blogger
A Dynamic challenge
TIOLUWA   11/2/2010 1:31:05 PM
NO RATINGS

As hopeless as the problem of counterfeiting is, i believe it can be reduced, though not totally eradicated. However, i don't think there is a global solution that can solve it.

Each market for counterfeit products has its unique properties and challenges. counterfeit drugs need to be tackled differently from counterfeit electronics, and these even need to be addressed differently based on the country and region.

In a developed world (its obvious that things work differently in developed and developing economies) laws, regulations and the likes could work, but in developing economies, regulations don't work, because there are not enough affordable alternative to the counterfeit goods.

In the case of developing countries, first there must be a development of affordable alternatives before the counterfeit market can be tackled, else, it would amount to a pointless battle.

Barbara Jorgensen
User Rank
Blogger
Counterfeiting in the channel
Barbara Jorgensen   11/2/2010 9:15:48 AM
NO RATINGS

I read an interesting article yesterday--http://www.marketwire.com/press-release/1-Source-Responds-to-VisionTech-Counterfeit-Electronic-Component-Scandal-1343228.htm

It doesn't look to me as if 1-Source is an authorized distributor, but it is taking advantage of VisionTech's problems to promote its own "anti-counterfeiting" measures. These measures include buying an inspection company headquartered in China--which, BTW, is where the parts that got VisionTech in trouble came from.

Don't get me started.....

Backorder
User Rank
Supply Network Guru
Inevitable?
Backorder   10/30/2010 9:19:55 AM
NO RATINGS

I think the problem of counterfeit products is hard to eradicate. There are couple of factors. One, it is very easy to reverse engineer and then duplicate a product down to packaging and similar branding(SONNY?). Secondly, there are takers. There is only a small percentage of buyers who actually dont realize that it is a counterfeit product. In developing countries where a lot of these "made in china" products find market, people have an opinion that technology is overpriced by standard brands and a similar functionality can be developed at a lower cost as well. This is where Chinese products enter. And they are not always of very poor quality, sometimes serving pretty decently and hence gaining word of mouth marketing. Although, as far as semiconductors are concerned and especially the medical industry manufacturers are wary of fake products. Thet take the precaution of supplying through authorized disties only and rarely go for chinese alternatives.

Bolaji Ojo
User Rank
Blogger
Re: Indeed a problem
Bolaji Ojo   10/29/2010 4:41:48 PM
NO RATINGS

Knock-offs have been around for as long as there have been something worth imitating. That history is here to stay. However, the danger is growing that the stakes are getting higher and higher with potential dmanages not just to a business but also to people. Recent reports indicate that counterfeit goods have been built into critical medical equipment, causing them to malfunction, and they've been identified in the military and aviation supply chain. The risks to people and governments are growing and efforts must be combined to fight the problem.

The challenge is that suppliers of high-tech components would never be caught dead discussing the likelihood of their supplies being tainted. They know the problem exist but can't or won't admit to it because it would reflect poorly on them. So, they proceed with efforts to fight the problem at their company level and hesitate to team up with other victims. Component distributors, on the other hand, readily talk about this because a clean supply is critical to their business and they can also use this as a weapon to fight for the exclusive rights to represent suppliers and have buyers procure components only from "franchise" distributors. Can anyone blame them? No.

Ariella
User Rank
Supply Network Guru
Re: Indeed a problem
Ariella   10/29/2010 4:08:05 PM
NO RATINGS

The dangerous ramifications of counterfeit medicines was touched on back in 1949 in the movie The Third Man. Sick children who were given diluted antibiotics either died or were damaged for life. In that case, it was not individuals but hospitals and clinics that were hoodwinked.  While generics that use the same ingredients as name brands can be just as effective, and some insurance drug coverage really pushes for generics, diluted ingredients are another story.

DennisQ
User Rank
Supply Network Guru
Re: Indeed a problem
DennisQ   10/29/2010 3:48:43 PM
NO RATINGS

Counterfeiting impacts the economy in so many negative ways: consumers are exposed to potentially serious health and safety risks

That's certainly true, especially when you're talking about the dangers of counterfiet medication.

Producing a cheap, barely-working iPhone knockoff is one thing, but producing useless or outright harmful medicine... well, that's obviously an order of magnitude worse.

Again, another problem that hits the developing world harder, but one which Americans are not immune to. We've all received spam mail ads for sleazy online pharmacies, and the reason we do is because there's a market, there are people out there that actually utilize them. For some reason, I am very skeptical of the quality of their merchandise.

Anyhow, will be interesting to see how much and what kind of media coverage ACTA gets when (if?) it goes through. But as Dave pointed out, there does seem to be that one significant, glaring omission...


Dave Sasson
User Rank
Supply Network Guru
Re: Indeed a problem
Dave Sasson   10/29/2010 3:02:37 PM
NO RATINGS

James, this is a huge problem and product counterfeiting is a big business, which is estimated to cost hundreds of billions of dollars annually. Counterfeiting impacts the economy in so many negative ways: consumers are exposed to potentially serious health and safety risks; retailers and manufacturers are affected by the costs of recalls and the loos of reputation due to merchandise returned due to substandard quality, plus the additional costs of trying to enforce anti-counterfeiting measures through the supply chain, and of course major revenue loss.

 Also, It is estimated that 750,000 jobs in the US have been lost due to counterfeiting. 

As for what anti-counterfeiting measures are being taken to try and combat this global threat, coincidentally just a few weeks ago in early October, the US Trade Representative’s office released the first public copy of the latest “Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA)” which was finally made public after a long period of negotiations.   The main purpose of ACTA is to establish an international framework to combat the spread of counterfeit goods globally and to increase cooperation and enforcement efforts.

What impact measures like this will actually have is yet to be determined.  What I also found interesting were the countries and groups of countries involved in the negotiations that lead to latest ACTA document:

Australia, Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Canada, Cyprus, the Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Japan, the Republic of Korea, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Morocco, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Singapore, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom, the United Mexican States, the United States, and the European Union


Which important country is missing?

For those interested in getting a closer look at the text of the agreement, it can be viewed here: http://trade.ec.europa.eu/doclib/docs/2010/october/tradoc_146699.pdf

DennisQ
User Rank
Supply Network Guru
Indeed a problem
DennisQ   10/29/2010 2:44:16 PM
NO RATINGS

Is this as huge a problem as I think it is? And what measures or regulations are in place to control the flow of substandard goods?

Of course it's a huge problem. But this has been a problem for as long as there has been economic trade. It's nothing new.

Measures and regulations? Sure, they're nice to have, but will they solve or even reduce the problem? I doubt it. And the problem is only exacerbated in developing economies because there may very likely be not enough legitimate supply to meet demand anyhow.

If there is potential profit to be made off the sale of substandard or counterfeit goods, there will always be people who will find a way to take advantage of that opportunity. Yes, it's a problem now with electronics, it was a problem years ago with watches, it was a problem hundreds of years ago with street vendors selling fake jewelry.

There will always be a demand for bargains.



More Blogs from A Different World
New US legislation banning the production of some incandescent bulbs by 2010 will light a fire under LED lighting globally

Datasheets.com Parts Search

185 million searchable parts
(please enter a part number or hit search to begin)
EBN Dialogue / LIVE CHAT
EBN Dialogue enables you to participate in live chats with notable leaders and luminaries. Open to the entire EBN community of electronics supply chain experts, these conversations see ideas shared, comments made, and questions asked and answered in real time. Listed below are upcoming and archived chats. Stay tuned and join in!
Upcoming Dialogues
REMIND ME
Live Chat 10/30: Top 10 Metrics That Enhance Procurement Performance
We'll be talking about the 10 most important procurement performance metrics, from the old standards to new and emerging best-practices.
10/30/2014
Remind Me
Live Chat 11/06: Enterprise Risks, Intellectual Property & Supply Chains
Enterprise risk management (ERM) frameworks can be useful to identify, assess, and manage intellectual property (IP) risks that arise in supply chain compliance. We'll look at real-world examples and strategies for mitigating those risks.
11/6/2014
Remind Me
Archived Dialogues
Live Chat 10/16: Applying a Macroeconomic Lens to the Supply Chain
EBN blogger Apek Mulay will be our guest as we talk about how macroeconomic reforms have the potential to impact the supply chain.
Live Chat 9/25: Minimizing Risk in the Global Supply Chain
Dave Bowen, CEO of e-sourcing firm MarketMaker4, will be our guest as we explore ways to minimize and manage geo-political and corporate risk in supply chain and sourcing through the use of technology.
Latest Poll
EBN Newswire
COLUMBUS, OH AND PHOENIX   10/20/2014
Avnet Opens CenterPoint Value-Added Services Center in ...
PETALING JAYA, MALAYSIA   10/20/2014
Avnet Appointed as a Cisco IT Distributor in Malaysia
POINTE CLAIRE, QC, CANADA   10/20/2014
Future Electronics Promotes Harvatek’s UV LEDs Series
Twitter Feed
EBN Online Twitter Feed