Wearable: ‘Hardware Ponzi Scheme’

Consumer wearable devices are hitting the wall.

The market demand for body-worn gadgets has been declining all year, according to the latest report from by Argus Insights, a market research firm based in Los Gatos, Calif.

Are we surprised about this? Not really.

Argus Insights CEO and founder John Feland told EE Times, “Sixty percent of fitness band users stop using it within the first six months.” I think that rings true for most of us.

Let’s trace the enthusiasm curve. A consumer starts using his fitness band to count steps. One day, the thing tells him he isn’t walking enough. Really? he asks. I’m being judged by a device that doesn’t walk at all? So, when the fitness band’s battery dies, what’s the motivation for charging it again? So it can keep on nagging him? Better to just leave it in a drawer and forget about it.

“Fitness bands have a stickiness problem,” said Feland. “Designers put accelerometers around a wearable’s silicon. But for consumers, its novelty wears off quickly. They find there isn’t much else to do beyond counting steps.”

The rate of wearable demand is slowing post holiday 2014
(Source: Argus Insights)

The rate of wearable demand is slowing post holiday 2014

(Source: Argus Insights)

While many market research firms track sales and shipment numbers, Argus Insights is in the business of analyzing consumer reviews to predict demand. “It’s a methodology originally developed at Stanford Univ. in early 2000. It has proven that mindshare predicts demand,” said Feland.

The firm said that over the last 18 months, the wearable market has started to mature. 

Using data compiled from approximately 328,000 consumer reviews since January 2014, Argus Insights reveals that after the holiday season of 2013, consumers briefly lost interest in wearables before steadily increasing demand reached its high point in January this year. At that point, demand reached four times the level of a year earlier. However, since then, demand has slowed.

Included in the firm’s study are numerous wearable products such as fitness bands, smartwatches, smart glasses, and other sensor-enabled devices.

In contrast to fitness bands, smart watches in general, including Apple Watch, the Moto 360, and the LG Watch Urbane, “outperform fitness bands in the hearts of consumers,” according to Feland.

For period 7/1/2015 through 7/31/2015
(Source: Argus Insights)

For period 7/1/2015 through 7/31/2015

(Source: Argus Insights)

“Although it’s hardly a killer app, people use their smartwatches as an information snacking piece,” observed Feland. “Smart watches are like yapping puppies. They are needier, and users end up spending more time, trying to find apps or things they can do with their devices.” Hence, they are “stickier” than fitness bands.

Hardware Ponzi scheme
Feland bluntly put it: “Fitness bands are like hardware Ponzi schemes.” In order to sustain their business, suppliers of such devices need to be in perpetual motion. Keep selling new hardware to new customers, while coming up with new game-like content to keep users’ interest.

Even when old customers drop away and residual income sinks, hardware suppliers have to keep providing data services for their fitness bands, or customer mindshare disappears.

All the while, the price of fitness bands is racing to the bottom, said Feland. Xiaomi, for example, has slashed prices for its Fitbit-like gadgets, Mi Band. Its suggested retail price is only $13.

To read the rest of this article, visit EBN sister site EE Times.


4 comments on “Wearable: ‘Hardware Ponzi Scheme’

  1. apek
    August 28, 2015

    Supply Side Economics itself is a PONZI Scheme…the rest are just the results of the SUPPLY SIDE POLICIES

  2. kethan
    September 8, 2015

    well said

  3. mesetudes
    September 22, 2015

    Totally agree with your point of vue

  4. SandraDub
    September 22, 2015



    Well in my opnion your article tells the truth but thats a bit ambiguous still for me.  I mean the Scheme is okay but are you really sure it works well ?



Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.